ISSN 1446-4896 ISSUE 1, 2002, NUMBER 51
MARCH - MAY 2002
1) SOUTH AFRICAN FILM AND PUBLICATIONS REVIEW BOARD OVERTURNS ITS
OWN RESTRICTION ON HOMOPHOBIC BOOK:
An adults-only age restriction slapped on the homophobic book, "The Pink
Agenda: The Ruin of the Family" by Christian activists (sic) Christine
McCafferty and Peter Hammond has been overturned by a review board of the South
African Film and Publications Board. The book had been described as "the
worst example of homophobic hate speech ever published in South Africa."
The Board ruled in January 2002 that the book would have to carry a notice that
it was for sale only to people over 18. The reason given was because those under
18 might not be able to separate fact from fiction. At the time, the committee
was concerned that the book made assertions that were questionable, hence the
adults-only tag. The book's publishers Christian Liberty Books (tautology if
ever there was any! - Eds.) appealed against the decision and at the review
hearing the board ruled that the writers have the freedom to express any view
that cannot be conclusively proven to incite hatred or violence and lifted the
age restriction. (www.news24.com
- 4 May 2002)
2) TRADE UNIONISTS IN MARDI GRAS PARADE:
In a letter to the Sydney
Star Observer (14.3.02) Ken Davis, international programs manager APHEDA
--Union Aid Abroad-- demanded to know why it is that every year the trade
union group gets edited out of the two television broadcasts of the Sydney Gay
& Lesbian Mardi Gras parade?
This year dykes and fags with the trade unions were accompanied
by Sharan Burrow, president of the 2-million member ACTU and probably the
most significant political leader to take part in this year's parade. The
unionists marched beside an effigy of Workplace Relations Minister (is
this an oxymoron?)Tony Abbott as they took a political message to the 2002
Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras parade. Organisers described the Abbott effigy
as a "very lean version of Friar Tuck, with a strong influence of Mr Byrnes
from the Simpsons, with rosary beads, sack cloth and ashes." Workers Online(1.3.02)
reported that unionists marched with the backing of the MUA, AMWU, CFMEU,
IEU, NSWTF, CPSU, PSA, LHMU, FSU, NSW NURSES, AMIEU(MEAT WORKERS), FAAA,
NTEU, AND THE NSW LABOR COUNCIL. Red was to be used as a unifying theme,
because it signifies political challenge to the orthodoxy of conservatism.
( ALSO NOTE GAY AND LESBIAN TRADE UNION CONFERENCE IN SYDNEY DURING GAY
GAMES 2002 - see item17)
3) AIDS ACTIVISTS ARRESTED IN NEW YORK:
The International Gay and Lesbian Human Rights Commission (IGLHRC)
reported on 31 January 2002 that seven members of the AIDS Coalition to
Unleash Power (ACT-UP) New York had been arrested that morning. They were
protesting at the World Economic Forum (WEF) annual meeting which opened
that day in New York. The activists demanded that corporations pay for
the treatment of all their workers with HIV/AIDS and that the Bush Administration
substantially increase the US contribution to the Global AIDS Fund. IGLHRC
called for their immediate release of those arrested, stating "Their detention
will make us neither more secure nor more prosperous. Granting access to
medications to the millions of people living with HIV/AIDS will."
The United Nations Security Council confirmed in January 2001 that
the AIDS epidemic unaddressed is a threat to world security. James D. Wolfensohn,
head of the World Bank, acknowledged then that the epidemic "is being more
effective than war in destabilising countries."
4) SOUTH AFRICA REVERSES AIDS VIEWS:
A report in PlanetOut (26 April 2002) states that the South African
government has done a dramatic about-face in its approach to the AIDS epidemic,
according to international news reports
The PlanetOut report goes on to say that the government of President
Thabo Mbeki has announced it is abandoning its view that HIV does not cause
AIDS, but the president has stopped short of accepting a causal link between
HIV and AIDS as fact.
5)"MBEKI SMEARED ME" - AIDS EXPERT:
As President Mbeki lurches from one AIDS crisis to another in an AIDS-stricken
South Africa, the country's pre-eminent black AIDS scientist, Professor
Malegapuru Makgoba, has accused Thabo Mbeki's office of waging a campaign
of coercion and vilification against medical researchers who challenge
the president's unorthodox views on HIV, London's Guardian newspaper has
reported. Professor Makgoba revealed the extent of the pressure after an
official investigation cleared him of "leaking" his own organisation's
research, suppressed for months by the cabinet because the research concluded
that about 6 million South Africans would die of AIDS by the end of the
decade. Makgoba and other leading researchers accuse Essop Prahad, the
cabinet minister regarded as the President Mbeki's "enforcer," of putting
pressure on them to support the president's views and suggesting dissenters
should leave the country.
Head of the University of Natal's internationally recognised team of HIV experts,
Hoosen Coovadia, said that in the past two years the government had bypassed
scientists who disagreed with the president. "We have been totally isolated.
We know more about HIV and breastfeeding than probably anyone else in the world,
but, as researchers, we are ignored by government." (report in www.news24.com
- 17 May 2002)
6)AND STILL IN SOUTH AFRICA
Wouter Basson, widely reviled as "Dr Death", has had 46 charges of
murder, fraud and drug dealing dismissed by the Pretoria High Court in
April 2002 after the longest and most expensive trial in South African
history. Standing between Basson's accusers and a conviction was Judge
Willie Hartzenberg, a judge from the apartheid era, who made no secret
of who it was he most admired in his courtroom! Amongst some of the issues
dealt with in the court were Basson's claims that he had penetrated the
highly secret chemical warfare establishments in Britain, the US and even
one in Moscow during the Cold War as he worked with some of the worst killers
known to man -- amongst them anthrax, E.coli, HIV, Sarin nerve gas and
the ebola virus.
7) AGE OF CONSENT ISSUE IN NEW SOUTH WALES:
With the state of Western Australia changing its laws on age-of-consent
for gay males from 21 to 16, the spotlight has again fallen on New South
Wales, which is now the only state in Australia to have unequal discriminatory
age of consent laws for gay males. Age of consent is 18 for gay men in
NSW whereas it is 16 for heterosexual males! LGS has written to the Premier
of New South Wales asking when that government will change the law and
to date the response to both letters has been that the matter has been
referred to the NSW Attorney-General for a response. The Greens MP in the
NSW parliament is also pushing the issue. In a media release dated 24 April
2002 Greens MP Lee Rhiannon stated: "This is not some obscure medical-theological
conscience issue but a straightforward question of equal human rights."
8) EGYPT'S HOMOPHOBIA:
The Egyptian government has denied claims by a group of US Congress
members that it is persecuting gays. In March 2002, forty US lawmakers
sent a second letter to the Egyptian Embassy calling on the government
to stop persecuting homosexuals. The Egyptian Ambassador in the USA, Nabil
Fahmy, has replied to the letter, maintaining that his country does not
persecute gay men and stating there is no law explicitly forbidding homosexuality
in Egypt. Fahmy explained that a group of gay men arrested at a boat party
on the Nile "were convicted essentially under a law which penalises promiscuity/prostitution"
and "that there is no distinction or discrimination based on a person's
sexual orientation".
In past months Egypt has tried a large number of gay men, charging
them with "habitual practice of debauchery." Many of the men have been
sentenced to prison and hard labour. Many went through the public humiliation
of being examined to see if they had engaged in anal intercourse. The results
of these examinations were presented at hearings before the Supreme State
Security Prosecution.
The group of US Congress members replied to Fahmy, saying, "Your selective
invocation of certain human rights conventions when it suits your purposes,
and your ignoring of others when they don't, is unpersuasive." (Report
from Gay.com U.K. as reported in PlanetOut News, 21 May 2002)
The very latest news available at the time of publication of this newsletter,
from "the datalounge" on 1 June and quoting a BBC report of 28 May states
that court officials in Egypt say President Hosni Mubarak has intervened
and ordered the retrial of 21 men convicted last year on charges of "practising
sexual immorality", a local euphemism for homosexuality. In an order signed
by Mubarak the men will be freed while awaiting a new trial. The government
has also officially abandoned plans to retry 29 others found not guilty.
However, "Since November, Egypt has sentenced many other men for homosexual
conduct, in other trials," said Scott Long of the International Gay and
Lesbian Human Rights Commission, "and the arrests continue. The President's
reported action does nothing for other victims still in prison."
9) DE FACTO RIGHTS IN VICTORIA BOUND BY LAW:
The June 2002 issue of the Victorian Senior reported that Seniors in
de facto and same sex relationships are now entitled to share in their
partner's estate, if that person dies without a will. The law came
into effect on 8 November 2001.
Elizabeth Lomas, State Trustees managing director, said this meant
de facto and same sex partners now had the same rights to the estate as
the married partner provided the surviving partner met certain criteria.
These include that where there is both a married spouse and a domestic
partner (de facto or same sex) surviving and no will, the 'spouse's share
will be shared between the two partners. The proportion received by each
depends on the time the deceased lived with either of the respective partners.
That's in Victoria but what about the other Australian States and Territories?
Does the Australian Constitution need changing for the federal parliament
to some day make the law uniform along with age-of-consent? Any answer?
Let's know.
10) MELBOURNE
QUEER FILM FESTIVAL 14-24 MARCH 2002:
As ever, this film festival had some excellent films, but also, as
usual, we were not able to see all of the films - finances and time are
always limiting factors! There were some outstanding documentaries, amongst
which were four short films with the generic title of "The Colour of Sex".
A film about orthodox gay Jews, Trembling before G-d, was interesting,
but did not, in our opinion, merit it being an award-winning documentary,
which apparently it was. The two Southern African documentaries, Simon
and I: Steps for the Future - from South Africa, and Rainmakers from Zimbabwe
gave some interesting insights into the two neighbouring countries' responses
to homosexuality. The homophobic Zimbabwean president Mugabe's spectre
hung over the fight for human rights in Rainmakers. Some of the "straight"
films were entertaining but not anything above ordinary. All in all, these
Queer Film Festivals, held in Sydney during the Mardi Gras festival period
and in Melbourne a few months after the Midsumma festival period are worthwhile
additions to the filmlovers' diary.
11) SPAIDS:
Tree planting dates for 2002 were provided to SPAIDS by South Sydney
City Council as: 26 May 2002; 28 July 2002; 8 September 2002. The first,
Sunday May 26, could hardly be said to have been successful. Nevertheless,
a handful of faithful, encouraged by Sister Nun-Buoy and Mother Abbyss
of the Order of Perpetual Indulgence, did turn up on a reasonably sunny
day to plant Australian species. The SPAIDS co-ordinators, now resident
in Melbourne, are planning to attend the next planting on Sunday, 28 July,
in the hope that they may be able to whip more of the faithful to put on
garden gloves and come to Sydney Park, St Peters. Sydney's AIDS Groves
are one of the few fine existing memorials to those who have died from
the effects of the HIV/AIDS in the lesbian and gay communities.
12)AIDS COMMEMORATIVE MONUMENTS:
LGS learned from the Melbourne B.News, lesbian and gay community newspaper
that the Fairfield AIDS Memorial Garden in the grounds of the now closed
Fairfield infectious diseases hospital was rundown and in a neglected state.
It seems that this situation was due to the building programme of
the North Melbourne Institute of TAFE (NMIT). SPAIDS therefore approached
both NMIT and the union involved in the building project, the CFMEU, and
the Victorian AIDS Council(VAC).
VAC and the CFMEU have both responded very favourably to the problem
but no feedback from NMIT. We were concerned that access appeared to have
been denied because of the poor state of the memorial site especially as
the ashes of some of those who had died had been scattered by lovers or
families in the Memorial Garden.
On Sunday, 16 June, SPAIDS coordinators visited the closed hospital
and rebuilding project. We were conducted to the AIDS Memorial Garden
in the grounds by security personnel. We were told that the previous week
the whole site had been cleared and was now easily accessible. We were
agreeably surprised to find that really was the case. We were able to take
photographs and told that there was a 24-hour cover of the site. Visitors
were welcome.
SPAIDS would also like to list for historical and archival reasons all
AIDS commemorative monuments and/or gardens around Australia and we request
our readers to advise us of any such memorials omitted from this list:
*Sydney Park AIDS Memorial Groves
*Medlow Bath (AIDS )Memorial Park
*John Hunter Hospital AIDS Memorial Garden
*West Australian AIDS Memorial
*Fairfield House AIDS Memorial Fountain & Garden *Fairfield AIDS Memorial
Garden
These will be included on the SPAIDS web site and will be added to --
when and if further AIDS Memorials are established. Our web site is at
the top of each edition of the newsletter.
13) RESPONSE TO LETTER FROM ADAM CARR IN LGS NEWSLETTER NO.2 2001
from Peter Collard, Sydney
"I don't see the relevance of the number of G&Ls killed in New York
(Sept 11), nor are the numbers of G&Ls amongst the thousands killed by the
US bombing in Afghanistan, nor the number of G&Ls mindlessly caught up in
the US bloodlust for revenge relevant.
The fact that the Taliban regime was violently anti-gay is of little
relevance unless we are fighting to replace it with a pro-gay regime. The
Northern Alliance and other Afghan groups are all in support of islamic
law. The best that can be hoped for is the replacement of the barbaric
execution methods with those approved by the Bush dynasty --firing squad
or lethal injection. We are constantly told that this is NOT a war against
islam, and so islamic law will no doubt continue to be enforced by any
new regime --prolonging the anti-woman and anti-gay agenda of islam.
While the Taliban were a distasteful regime, they were the government
of Afghanistan and thereby entitled to make laws. Adam Carr does
not seem to be advocating all-out war against Zimbabwe, Malaysia or Israel
for their anti-gay laws; and I am sure that the defeat of an anti-gay
regime is not anywhere on the agenda of the US (unfortunate collateral
damage). One of the first acts of the US invaders was to liberate
people arrested and held for trial on lawful charges of promoting christianity
(the only good thing that the Taliban did).
I certainly do not support totalitarian or terrorist tactics, and I
consider the US regime to be totalitarian, fascist, anti-gay and terrorist.
The US wants to establish its law worldwide. David Hicks is held as a hostage
just as the Abu Sayef hold hostages in the Philippines. He has committed
no crime in Afghanistan, USA or Australia but is held in a cage, without
charge, consular access or legal representation, and may not be released
unless Australia promises to punish him (for his non-crime of politics
objectionable to the US). The Australian government is trying to introduce
detention without charge, and imprisonment for not speaking. So, not only
will we have no right to free speech, but no right to free silence as well
--in the name of fighting totalitarian terrorists.
The US claims to be protecting freedoms, but see what happened to Anthony Mundine
(the boxer) who expressed understanding of the motives of the terrorists. The
USA makes great threats to countries attempting to protect their industries,
invoking the WTO to get their way, but treats its allies in this "war"
with contempt by imposing import duties (contrary to its free
trade agenda) to protect its incompetent steel industry. The US insists on consular
access to its citizens arrested in other countries, but has been found guilty
in the world court of refusing consular access to prisoners in the US. I cannot
support a regime of such hypocrisy, and strongly suspect them of an ulterior
motive, taking this opportunity to justify the attack on Afghanistan. The official
dis-information service has been closed down , so now we should all believe
everything that the US says. But as Afghanistan seems not to have a sea border
we won't be hearing of Afghanis throwing babies into the sea, will we? "
Peter Collard's letter was dated 10 March 2002 (Editors)
We were recently sent photos of us carrying the Lesbian and Gay Solidarity banner at various demos in Melbourne since we moved here in 2001. This photo was taken on 24 March 2002 at the Palm Sunday rally, and the photo is with the kind permission of PC.
14) 30TH ANNIVERSARY OF THE MURDER OF DR GEORGE DUNCAN:
In 1972 George Duncan, a newly appointed lecturer to Adelaide University's
law school, was murdered by person or persons unknown on 10 May 1972 by
drowning in the Torrens River
in the heart of Adelaide. No people have been brought to justice
over the affair, and two of three policemen charged with manslaughter in
1986 were acquitted. Calls for a Royal Commission have always been ignored
and the mystery of who drowned George Duncan remains unsolved. Duncan's
death precipitated the first homosexual law reform in Australia - in South
Australia - but this was only partial reform. When Don Dunstan became premier
of South Australia in 1975 his government introduced full reform and South
Australia became the first state or territory to achieve full decriminalisation.
This year marks the 30th anniversary of Dr Duncan's murder and a play
is being performed in Adelaide about it. The Melbourne Star in its May
2 issue reported that the author, Ray Goodlass, considered Dr Duncan to
be Australia's gay martyr because his death precipitated the first major
homosexual law reform in this country. "I saw a play," Goodlass said, "
at the beginning of last year in Sydney called The Laramie Project, about
the Matthew Shepard bashing (murder) --the case in Wyoming in 1999. And
I thought, why is it that no one has written a play about our greatest
gay hero? So that was my stimulus."
15) AUSTRALIA'S ANTI-TERROR BILLS:
Under these bills, if passed into Australian Federal law, the federal
government can define anything it doesn't like as violent, including letter-writing!
What's more, the proposed penalties are exceptional. For instance, the
penalty for being a member of a banned organisation --25 years imprisonment;
for refusing to answer questions even under duress about what ASIO thinks
you may know about "terrorism" you face 5 years in jail; and if you are
charged with "an act of terrorism" and can't prove your innocence, you
face life in prison.
Tim Anderson, wrongly jailed as a "terrorist" in 1978 and later cleared,
now lectures in Political Economy at the University of Sydney, and has
this to say about the bills: " Any real 'terrorist act' is already
illegal. The real targets of these laws in Australia are not bomb throwers
or assassins. The new powers in Australia will be used selectively against
activist targets, marginalised groups and individuals, and racial minorities."
*Some extensive powers in the bills are expected to be amended
such as determining which political and religious groups can now legally
exist and instead of indefinite detention without being charged with a
crime, there is likely to be detention without charge for 7 days. Detainees
could be allowed to have access to an approved lawyer but only after
the Law Council lawyer selected has been vetted by ASIO. Proposed changes
to the Telecommunications Interception Act --part of the package of anti-terrorism
amendments-- will make it easier for police to read a suspect's emails
than it is to tap a phone or search premises. And ' a suspect' may be a
person only thought by ASIO to know about someone else on its list.
*Because these proposed terror laws will affect us all from letter-writers
to blockaders, from striking trade union members to financial supporters of
Greenpeace, the 7 bills must be opposed at this stage any way people --including
lesbian and gay activists - see fit.
*It's too late to put in a submission to the Senate and Joint Parliamentary
Inquiries but it's not too late to phone in your opposition to these knee-jerk
bills (or send an email - or a letter) to your local federal member.
*For text of the bills, try website: www.aph.gov.au/senate/committee/legcon_ctte/ASIO/ASIO.pdf
16) GERMANY OFFERS NAZI-ERA PARDONS:
A PlanetOut news item on 20 May 2002 reported that German lawmakers
had completed the pardon process for thousands of Nazi-era army deserters
and homosexuals sent to concentration camps and prisons during World War
II. About 50,000 gay men and 22,000 deserters were included in the pardon
passed by the lower house in Berlin, an extension of a 1998 law that cleared
the names of hundreds of thousands of Germans convicted of crimes under
the Nazis.
Of the estimated 50,000 homosexuals convicted by the Nazis, few ever
came forward after World War II because of the continuing stigma - as well
as the fact that Paragraph 175, the law under which they were convicted,
remained on the books of West Germany until 1969.
17) CONFERENCES:
Australian Homosexual Histories Conference 5: 28 and 29 October
2002 - Newcastle
home.vicnet.au/~alga/ahh5.htm
Queer Studies Conference:
29 and 30 October 2002 - Newcastle
www.newcastle.edu.au/school/newc-business/irhr/qs
2nd World Conference of Lesbian and Gay
Trade Unionists: 31 October -
2 November 2002 - Sydney
www.constructionzone.com.au/workers
4th National LGTB Health Conference
--Health in Difference: 31 October
- 2 November 2002 - Sydney
www.healthindifference.org
It would appear conference goers will have to select those conferences
which are of most interest to them and make their bookings accordingly,
remembering of course that there are two different cities involved!
18) RESEARCH PROJECT: ATTITUDES TOWARDS HOMOSEXUAL YOUTH SUICIDE
IN BOTH HETEROSEXUAL AND HOMOSEXUAL COMMUNITIES:
In March 2002 LGS received a request for people to take part in this
important aspect of gay and lesbian research. If anybody wishes to take
part in the project and complete a survey questionnaire, please contact
Mari Molloy who is currently a student of the University of Ballarat, Victoria,
and who is in her second year of a professional Doctorate Degree in Clinical
Psychology. Mari can be contacted at: minxta@hotmail.com
19) SOME PITHY COMMENTS ABOUT THE CURRENT "TERROR WAR":
First it was to be a Crusade. Then it became the "War for Civilisation."
Then the "War without End." Then the "War Against Terror." And now
--believe it or not-- President Bush is promising us a "Titanic War on
Terror." (Robert Fisk in The Independent, 13 June 2002)
These religious nutters are people I've been criticising and
fighting against for the best part of my life. But these are also people
the US created and trained and funded. (Tariq Ali, author of The Clash
of Fundamentalisms and recently in Australia, The Age, 6 June 02)
Australians have been drawn into this 'war' in much the same
way as earlier wars. We have come to expect conservative Federal Governments
to fall over themselves, in an effort to please the US Government, as they
did during the Vietnam war. So the Howard Government throws troops into
a dangerous Afghan operation with no clear goals, echoes George Bush's
partisan comments about Palestinians, threatens to involve Australians
in aggressive US designs on Iraq, and draws up a list of unprecedented
harsh powers to deny Australian citizens their basic rights. (Tim Anderson
on the net)
We have had time now to absorb the 'Fortress Australia" Budget.
But does anyone out there feel the slightest bit better protected? Or safer?
I, for one, feel less safe, knowing that critical decisions about what
actually supports and develops a safe society are being made by people
who are apparently so out of touch with reality and basic commonsense.
(Stephanie Dowrick, writer & broadcaster in Good Weekend, 1 June 2002)
Virtually all terrorist acts involve what might be called ordinary
crimes --murder, kidnapping, assault, malicious damage and so on-- albeit
for political motives. (Justice Hope, Australia's Protective Security Review,
1979)
Plant a tree on SUNDAY, 28 JULY 2002 in memory
of someone who has died from HIV/AIDS. Young
Australian trees supplied by South Sydney Council,
11am to 3pm, free barbecue lunch around midday.
-off Barwon Park Road, ST PETERS. Parking avail.
CURRENT NEWSLETTER AND ARCHIVE OF PREVIOUS NEWSLETTERS
MannieBlog (from 1 August 2003 to 31 December 2005)
ACTIVIST KICKS BACKS - AKB (from December 2005 onwards)
RED JOS BLOGSPOT (from January 2009 onwards)
CURRENT NEWSLETTER AND ARCHIVE OF PREVIOUS NEWSLETTERS
Mannie has a personal web site: RED JOS: HUMAN RIGHTS ACTIVISM
Mannie's blogs may be accessed by clicking on to the following links:
MannieBlog (from 1 August 2003 to 31 December 2005)
Activist Kicks Backs - Blognow archive re-housed - 2005-2009
RED JOS BLOGSPOT (from January 2009 onwards)
This page updated 18 SEPTEMBER 2014 and again on 23 APRIL 2017
Page 50